(Photo credit: Amy Rose/Fourth Estate)
Last Thursday, President Obama and a handful of selected invitees sat down in Dewberry Hall for a televised forum moderated by CNN’s Anderson Cooper to discuss Obama’s recent executive action on gun control. Just outside the town hall, students and community members waged a protest over the same issues being discussed inside.
Around 7 p.m., around 25 protesters who stood against Obama’s executive actions gathered in front of EagleBank Arena. After everyone had arrived, the group with signs in hand started its march to the Johnson Center where members converged with about 25 additional protesters. Across from the group, separated only by a few strands of caution tape, stood 50 other protesters in favor of Obama’s actions.
For the first few tense minutes, loud chanting and insults were hurled across the gap between the opposing groups. Eventually, the yelling died down, and the two sides spent the rest of the protest divided, conversing among themselves and and staring down the opposition.
On Tuesday, January 5, Obama announced a series of executive actions aiming to reduce gun violence. He added that he would attend a town hall at Mason to discuss his actions in further depth. After finding out the location of the event, students like senior Devon Flynn, a government and international politics major, and Mason alum Storm Paglia decided to create a Facebook page in hopes of getting a group together to protest the town hall.
“The purpose of this protest is to support the Second Amendment and oppose President Obama’s anti-gun agenda,” read the Facebook page Flynn created, Protest Obama Gun Control “Town Hall.”
An email from Mason Interim Police Chief Thomas Longo warned the university community that guns might be present at the protest, but none were visible among the protesters.
Flynn said the proper way for Obama to address the issue of gun violence would have been to go through Congress. Flynn said he does not believe it is right that Obama used executive action with disregard to all other options.
“In the executive orders [Obama] was talking about mental health, that’s one of the measures I do support. Everything else I think is infringing on people’s rights,” Flynn said.
Sophomore criminology major William Hicks said he joined the protest because he does not believe the executive actions put in place by Obama will be effective in the long run. He said crazy people will always find a way to obtain guns, despite background checks.
Eddie Weingart, D.C. resident and founder of the Project to End Gun Violence, stood with the group that supported Obama’s actions. According to their Tumblr account, Project to End Gun Violence is a coalition of proactive D.C.-area citizens who are focused on addressing gun violence in the U.S. at the local, state and national levels.
“I came out [tonight] because I am a gun violence survivor, and I want to thank President Obama for his executive order that he’s signing this week. I think it’s a very important step in the fight to reduce the gun violence epidemic,” Weingart said.
Andy Goddard, whose son was injured at the Virginia Tech shooting in 2007, was also on Obama’s side.
“My son is on the inside there [Dewberry Hall]. My son is a survivor from Virginia Tech. He was shot four times at the Virginia Tech [shooting] and I have been working on this issue since that time because we need to do something different,” Goddard said.
He added that even though the president’s executive actions do not amount to much, they are better than what Congress has been able to accomplish to address gun violence.
The anti-gun control protesters also came to the event with another issue in mind. The group was unhappy when members realized the town hall was not open to the public and that the audience members were hand-selected by CNN.
In an email sent to the Mason community on January 5, Renell Wynn, vice president of Communications and Marketing at Mason, announced that CNN would be holding an invitation-only town hall and no tickets would be available.
Michael Sandler, director of Strategic Communications at Mason, said closing the town hall to the public was not the university’s decision.
“The CNN event with President Barack Obama was planned and run by CNN. Mason’s involvement was to provide the venue via a contract and support based on the terms of that contract,” Sandler said.
Students, like Flynn and others, took issue with the town hall being closed to the public.
Freshman Amanda Funk, a nursing major, said closing the town hall to the public was cowardly and that to call it a town hall was actually a lie.
Freshman Grant Pitarys, a math and economics major, agreed with Funk.
“This felt like another instance of GMU selling out just like it did with EagleBank, it essentially just pimped out the J.C. [Johnson Center] Gold Room for CNN without letting [in] any student association that might be relevant to attend,” Pitarys said. “I don’t know of any student who was invited, and it just felt disappointing. Even worse was that CNN called this a town hall, but it wasn’t a town hall for us students because of how private it was.”
This disappointment and concern over Obama’s use of executive action led Flynn and his fellow protesters to shout their concerns outside the Johnson Center. The president himself may not have heard them, but their voices were loud and clear nonetheless.
nick
I went to the protest and it was a lot of fun.
I’m in favor of having the option of owning a gun for self defense, but I’m always happy to talk to people with other views.
Unfortunately when I tried to talk to people on the other side, one woman (maybe their leader?) would call out “don’t even engage him!” and end any discussion. It’s a shame, because I feel deep down we all have the goal of making America a safer place — I just don’t think restricting the ability of law-abiding citizens to defend themselves is going to achieve that.
Later on when I tried walking through the anti-gun side (not even talking to anyone, just to see if I knew anyone there) an older gentleman informed me he was going to have the police remove me from the event for not staying on “my side”. But, nothing happened and overall I found most people to be civil with one another.
I did find it ironic though that such an event would be held at a university named for George Mason, who co-authored the 2nd Amendment and who once said that to disarm the people was the best and most effectual way to enslave them.
Anyway I caught the town hall later on and I give Obama credit for speaking without his teleprompter and taking some tough questions from the opposition. (Notably absent were any questioners who had successfully used a firearm in self defense, I guess even Obama realized that would have completely undermined his case that you have to be trained like a Navy SEAL to properly use a gun).
I just wish he would have done more research on the topic first. For example he and Joe Biden have recently become infatuated with the idea of smart guns. Unlike either of them I actually do own a smart gun, and the technology is nothing like what they describe. It might stop your three year old kid from shooting himself, but it’s not going to do anything to prevent suicides, criminal homicides, terrorists, mass shooters, or anyone else who can figure out that it only takes a screwdriver and 60 seconds to disable the mechanism. There’s also big drawbacks in terms of cost and limited smart gun models that make this technology impractical for many people, plus concerns over reliability. If you are concerned about junior shooting himself, I would suggest investing in a gun safe and retention holster.
I would have rather seen an emphasis on gun safety education, safe gun storage, conflict resolution and reaching out to people who feel isolated from society. Well, maybe next time.
Pingback: [BLOCKED BY STBV] Mason project gives students safe space to discuss guns in America | Fourth Estate
Pingback: [BLOCKED BY STBV] Keeping the safety on | Fourth Estate